Warm the milk to 86°F. If you're using fresh milk straight from the cow, it will already be close to your target temperature. Otherwise, slowly warm the milk using a double boiler or water bath to avoid scorching.
Sprinkle the starter culture over the surface of the milk. Allow it to rehydrate for 5 minutes.
Using an up-and-down motion, gently stir for about 2 minutes. Imagine lifting the milk from the bottom of the pot to the top while disturbing the surface as little as possible.
Allow the milk to ripen for 90 minutes while maintaining 86°F. The milk will still look like milk when this step is finished. Nothing dramatic happens during ripening, and that's completely normal.
If using pasteurized milk, stir in the diluted calcium chloride. Skip it when using fresh raw milk.
Wait 5 minutes, then add the diluted rennet using the same gentle up-and-down stirring motion.
Allow the milk to sit undisturbed for 45-60 minutes.
Begin checking for a clean break after about 45 minutes. To test, insert a clean finger or knife into the curd at a slight angle and gently lift. A properly set curd will split cleanly, with clear whey filling the gap.
Cut the curd into ½-inch cubes. I use a whisk.
Allow the curds to rest undisturbed for 10 minutes to heal. Maintain the temperature at 86°F during this time.
Gently stir the curds in the whey for 10 minutes. The goal is simply to keep the curds suspended and prevent them from matting together.
Drain the whey down to the level of the curds. Using a ladle, carefully transfer the curds into the molds. At first, the molds will look dramatically overfilled. Don't worry. Camembert curds contain a lot of moisture. As whey drains away, the wheels will shrink considerably over the next several hours.
Flip the cheeses three times over the next 5 hours. Continue draining overnight, or approximately 12 hours total.
Once draining is complete, gently rub non-iodized cheese salt or kosher salt over the entire surface of each wheel, including the top, bottom, and sides. You don't need to measure an exact amount. Simply use enough to lightly coat the surface of the cheese.
Place the cheeses into your prepared aging containers and move them to a wine fridge, cheese cave, or refrigerator.
Turn the cheeses daily with clean hands. You can also wear cooking gloves if you want to be extra careful. We don't want to accidentally inoculate our rinds with any wild bacteria!